A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada’s Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing

Save
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada’s Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing

Information

  • Project Name: A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development
  • Student Name: Stefina Stephen Palliyil
  • Softwares/Plugins: AutoCAD , Sketchup , Twinmotion , Adobe Photoshop , Adobe Illustrator
More Info Less Info

Excerpt: A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada’s Identity Amidst Vertical Development’ is an architecture thesis on urban housing by Stefina Stephen Palliyil from the Manchester School of Architecture (MSA) that seeks to preserve the identity and culture of the Kumbharwada community from Dharavi, Mumbai, against the pressures of urban redevelopment. The proposal presents a vertically integrated complex that combines residential and workspace areas for potters, enabling them to sustain their craft in a modern urban environment.

Introduction: Identity is a nuanced concept that is often entwined with unique experiences and memories. This raises the question: is our society becoming more antisocial and introverted as a result of urbanisation? On the other hand, much of India remains non-urbanized, with communities holding on to their traditions, roots, and social ties.

Research Question: How can a feminist approach be employed to sustain the identity of the Kumbharwada community of Dharavi amidst vertical development?

The thesis proposes a vertically integrated complex that blends residential and workspace areas for potters, enabling them to sustain their craft within a vibrant, modern urban environment. This complex aims to safeguard the identity and culture of the Kumbharwada community against the pressures of urban redevelopment by optimizing land use and meeting the demands of a growing population.

Save

Site Context

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Economic Model
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Analysis – Existing Condition

Situated in Dharavi, the traditional home of the Kumbharwada community, the site chosen for the vertical pottery colony ensures continuity and close proximity to their pre-existing networks and markets. This project prioritizes the provision of suitable workspaces and equipment for potters, adequate living accommodations for potter families, and affordable rental options for migrants seeking housing within the community.

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing

Engaging with stakeholders to advocate for this feminist approach is crucial, as it aims to balance the need for vertical urban growth with the preservation of social connections and cultural identity. By fostering vertical interactions and social exchanges, the design will support the unique culture of Kumbharwada, helping to protect it amidst urban redevelopment pressures. Prompt implementation will ensure that the needs of the increasing population are met while maintaining the community’s heritage and identity.

Design Process

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Program Development & Analysis– Living Quarter
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Program Development– Pottery Work

The design process began with a functional and spatial analysis, mapping out activities in the Wadis like pottery making, washing clothes, and social gatherings. This analysis focused on understanding space utilisation and identifying multifunctional areas essential to the community’s culture.

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Programmatic Brief & Actors
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Vertical Wadi

In the concept development phase, the vertical integration concept was introduced to incorporate Wadi functions into a vertical framework, transforming open spaces into social hubs at different levels. Cultural preservation was prioritised, ensuring the design maintained spaces for traditional activities and social interactions.

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Pottery Workspace Design Process
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Pottery’s Unit Design Process
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Extended Family Unit Design Process

Finally, during design prototyping, the vertical complex was zoned for specific functions, such as pottery workspaces, residential units, and communal areas. Vertical connections, including elevators, staircases, and ramps, were designed to encourage interaction and ease of movement throughout the complex. 

Final Outcome

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Masterplan – Ground floor

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Typical Neighborhood – Section

A feminist approach to equity in Kumbharwada involves eschewing mass production in favor of artisanal craftsmanship, thereby preserving the community’s cultural integrity. This design prioritizes vertical interactions, fostering a close-knit community dynamic within an urbanized structure. By balancing the city’s need for vertical growth with the preservation of social connections and cultural identity, the design fosters a sustainable urban environment.

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Typical Neighborhood Plan – Ground Floor

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Pottery Workspace – Ground Floor Plan and Elevation
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Pottery Workspace – Floor Plans and Section

Vertical integration encourages connections and interactions at different levels, transforming traditional lanes, known as “Woman’s Wadi,” into social and activity hubs distributed throughout the building. This approach promotes a sense of community by creating spaces for social exchanges and communal activities at various vertical stages. Residents can engage in traditional practices while adapting to contemporary urban living.

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Building with Community
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Adaptability of Individual Units
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Feminist Details

Building with the community is integral to this approach. The people of Kumbharwada, who have historically built their own houses, will participate in the construction process. Under the guidance of an architect, they will create their own materials and design their own walls, ensuring that their unique cultural identity is reflected in the new structure.

A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Pottery Workspace
A Feminist Approach in Sustaining Kumbharwada's Identity Amidst Vertical Development at Dharavi, Mumbai | Masters Design Thesis on Urban Housing
Festive space

Conclusion: This project showcases a thoughtful integration of vertical elements that ensures the Kumbharwada community can sustain its rich cultural legacy and livelihood while addressing the needs of an increasing population and modern urban challenges. It not only maintains the cultural heritage but also empowers the community to thrive amidst urban pressures.

[This Academic Project has been published with text submitted by the student]

To submit your academic project for publication at ArchiDiaries, please visit the following link >> Submit

Leave a Reply